Receiving Helpdesk

why quick sort is not stable

by Trudie Runte Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

QuickSort is an unstable algorithm because we do swapping of elements according to pivot’s position (without considering their original positions). How to make QuickSort stable? Recommended: Please try your approach on {IDE} first, before moving on to the solution. Quicksort can be stable but it typically isn’t implemented that way.

QuickSort is an unstable algorithm because we do swapping of elements according to pivot's position (without considering their original positions).Jun 15, 2022

Full Answer

How to make quicksort stable?

  • Produce a new array B such that B [ i] is the ordered pair ( A [ i], i).
  • Sort B using a comparison function that compares the first value and compares the second value if the first one is equal. ...
  • Change sorted- B into sorted- A by just taking the first value from each pair.

Why is quick sort and merge sort called stable algorithms?

Quick sort is not a stable algorithm because the swapping of factors is done in step with pivot's function (with out thinking about their unique positions). A sorting set of rules is said to be stable if it continues the relative order of data within the case of equality of keys.

Is quick sort truly the fastest sorting algorithm?

  • Insertion Sort : Time complexity is O (n^2) but the sort is very efficient when n is very small.
  • Merge Sort : Performance is O (nlogn) in worst case and average case but takes extra space of O (n).
  • Quick Sort : Performance is O (nlogn) in average case but can go to O (n^2) in worst case. ...
  • Heap Sort : Performance is O (nlogn) in average case

Why quick sort is called Quick sort?

  • What is the average case run time complexity of Quick Sort? The average case run time of quick sort is O (n logn) . ...
  • Is Quick Sort a stable algorithm? ...
  • Is Quick Sort an inplace algorithm? ...
  • What is Randomised Quick Sort? ...
  • Why Quick Sort is better than Merge Sort? ...
  • Which is faster quick sort or merge sort? ...
  • Where is quick sort used? ...

Is quick sort stable or not?

Quicksort is a comparison sort, meaning that it can sort items of any type for which a "less-than" relation (formally, a total order) is defined. Efficient implementations of Quicksort are not a stable sort, meaning that the relative order of equal sort items is not preserved.

How do I stabilize Quicksort?

Quicksort is stable when no item is passed unless it has a smaller key....There is a good example.Use the middle element as the pivot.Create two lists, one for smaller, the other for larger.Iterate from the first to the last and put elements into the two lists.

What are the disadvantages of quick sort?

DisadvantagesIt is recursive. Especially, if recursion is not available, the implementation is extremely complicated.It requires quadratic (i.e., n2) time in the worst-case.It is fragile, i.e. a simple mistake in the implementation can go unnoticed and cause it to perform badly.

Which sorting algorithm is not stable?

Stable and Unstable Sorting Algorithms Several common sorting algorithms are stable by nature, such as Merge Sort, Timsort, Counting Sort, Insertion Sort, and Bubble Sort. Others such as Quicksort, Heapsort and Selection Sort are unstable. We can modify unstable sorting algorithms to be stable.

How do you make a stable sort?

There can be sorting algo specific ways to make it stable, but in general, any comparison based sorting algorithm which is not stable by nature can be modified to be stable by changing the key comparison operation so that the comparison of two keys considers position as a factor for objects with equal keys.

Is quicksort adaptive?

Most classic sorting algorithms, such as Quicksort, Heapsort [6, 23], and Mergesort [11], are not adaptive: their time complexity is Θ(n log n) irrespectively of the input.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Mergesort?

Merge sort, advantages and disadvantagesIt is quicker for larger lists because unlike insertion and bubble sort it doesnt go through the whole list seveal times.It has a consistent running time, carries out different bits with similar times in a stage.

Does QuickSort need external memory?

Abstract. An external sorting algorithm based on quicksort is presented. The file to be sorted is kept on a disk and only those blocks are fetched into the main memory which are currently needed.

Why QuickSort better than merge sort?

Quick sort is an in-place sorting algorithm. In-place sorting means no additional storage space is needed to perform sorting. Merge sort requires a temporary array to merge the sorted arrays and hence it is not in-place giving Quick sort the advantage of space.

What is stable and unstable sorting?

A sorting algorithm is said to be stable if it maintains the relative order of numbers/records in the case of tie i.e. if you need to sort 1 1 2 3 then if you don't change the order of those first two ones then your algorithm is stable, but if you swap them then it becomes unstable, despite the overall result or ...

What is stability of sorting algorithms?

Stable sorting algorithms maintain the relative order of records with equal keys (i.e. values). That is, a sorting algorithm is stable if whenever there are two records R and S with the same key and with R appearing before S in the original list, R will appear before S in the sorted list.

Which is the slowest sorting algorithm?

Originally Answered: Which is the slowest sorting procedure? Insertion Sort can be considered the slowest sorting algorithm as it has a run-time complexity of O(n2) i.e. order of n square.

What is stable sorting?

A sorting algorithm is said to be stable if two objects with equal keys appear in the same order in sorted output as they appear in the input unsorted array. Some sorting algorithms are stable by nature like Insertion sort, Merge Sort, Bubble Sort, etc. And some sorting algorithms are not, like Heap Sort, Quick Sort, etc.

How to sort 6 columns?

To sort 6 columns, a sort is done with the least significant 3 columns, followed by a sort with the most significant 3 columns. A classic example of a stable radix sort is a card sorter, used to sort by a field of base 10 numeric columns. The cards are sorted from least significant digit to most significant digit.

How many bins are there in a card sorter?

Actual card sorters have more than 10 bins since there are 12 zones on a card, a column can be blank, and there is a mis-read bin. To sort letters, 2 passes per column are needed, 1st pass for digit, 2nd pass for the 12 11 zone.

Why is stability important?

One is that, if two records don't need to be swapped by swapping them you can cause a memory update, a page is marked dirty, and needs to be re-written to disk (or another slow medium). Share. Improve this answer.

What to do if you don't need stability?

If you don't need stability, you can use a fast, memory-sipping algorithm from a library, like heapsort or quicksort, and forget about it. If you need stability, it's more complicated. Stable algorithms have higher big-O CPU and/or memory usage than unstable algorithms.

Is a sorting algorithm stable?

A sorting algorithm is said to be stable if two objects with equal keys appear in the same order in sorted output as they appear in the input array to be sorted. Some sorting algorithms are stable by nature like Insertion sort, Merge Sort, Bubble Sort, etc. And some sorting algorithms are not, like Heap Sort, Quick Sort, etc.

Is sorting meaningless?

If you assume what you are sorting are just numbers and only their values identify/distinguish them (e.g. elements with same value are identicle), then the stability-issue of sorting is meaningless. However, objects with same priority in sorting may be distinct, and sometime their relative order is meaningful information.

What is Quick Sort and how is it associated with Algorithms?

Quick Sort is a sorting algorithm, which is commonly used in computer science. Quick Sort is a divide and conquer algorithm. It creates two empty arrays to hold elements less than the pivot value and elements greater than the pivot value, and then recursively sort the sub arrays.

Quick Sort Algorithm: Steps on how it works

Find a “pivot” item in the array. This item is the basis for comparison for a single round.

Quick Sort: An example

Here is an example of writing the Quick Sort Algorithm based on the steps I provided earlier. Below I have written a function, which accept the following parameter: an array. The function returns the sorted array.

Why is Quicksort called Quicksort?

The name comes from the fact that it sorts data faster than any commonly available sorting algorithm and like Merge sort, it also follows the divide and conquer principle. Quicksort, in particular, is an interesting one nevertheless it takes enough time to get your head around it. Quicksort breaks down the problem of sorting ...

Why is it important to shuffle items in Quicksort?

Shuffling the item gives better randomness in elements position thereby helping the quicksort to perform better.

Is Quicksort an in-place algorithm?

It needs memory in order of O (log n) this completely disqualifies quicksort as an in-place algorithm. However, quicksort is always considered to be in-place, it sorts the elements within the array with at most a constant amount of them outside the array at any given time.

Is Quicksort parallel or parallel?

This is often referred to as parallel quicksort. Quicksort is widely approved if you look closer we can see the quick sort is builtin in most of the language’s own sort implementation. Java’s systems programmers have chosen to use quicksort ( with 3-way partitioning) to implement the primitive-type methods.

Does Quicksort perform badly?

If the list of elements is already in sorted order or nearly sorted order then it takes n² comparisons to sort the array. Yes, there are cases where Quicksort performs badly.

When does Quicksort's best case occur?

Quicksort's best case occurs when the partitions are as evenly balanced as possible: their sizes either are equal or are within 1 of each other. The former case occurs if the subarray has an odd number of elements and the pivot is right in the middle after partitioning, and each partition has elements.

How does Quicksort's worst case and average case running times differ?

Suppose that we're really unlucky and the partition sizes are really unbalanced. In particular, suppose that the pivot chosen by the partition function is always either the smallest or the largest element in the -element subarray. Then one of the partitions will contain no elements and the other partition will contain elements—all but the pivot. So the recursive calls will be on subarrays of sizes 0 and .

Can you randomly choose an element in a subarray?

Instead, you could randomly choose an element in the subarray, and use that element as the pivot. But wait—the partition function assumes that the pivot is in the rightmost position of the subarray. No problem—just swap the element that you chose as the pivot with the rightmost element, and then partition as before.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9