Receiving Helpdesk

why does the paradox of value exist

by Laney Rodriguez Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

paradox of value the proposition that the value (PRICE) of a good is determined by its relative scarcity rather than by its usefulness. Water is extremely useful and its TOTAL UTILITY is high but, because it is generally so abundant, its MARGINAL UTILITY (and, hence, price) is low.

The paradox of value examines why goods that are not essential to life can command a much higher price than goods that are essential to life. For example, a classic example is the price of water and diamonds. Diamonds are mere accoutrements and jewellery, yet they can sell for thousands of pounds.Nov 10, 2021

Full Answer

How would you describe the paradox of value?

Want a daily email of lesson plans that span all subjects and age groups?

  • 2,170,997 Views
  • 22,586 Questions Answered
  • TED Ed Animation

How does marginal utility explain the paradox of value?

The paradox of value is based on the law of diminishing marginal utility. The marginal utility determines the value in use of an item and the value of the exchange. There is more value in using water. On the other hand, diamonds have more value in exchange. There is no greater value in the exchange of water and no greater value in the use of diamonds.

What are 5 examples of a paradox?

Here are some thought-provoking paradox examples:

  • Save money by spending it.
  • If I know one thing, it’s that I know nothing.
  • This is the beginning of the end.
  • Deep down, you’re really shallow.
  • I’m a compulsive liar.
  • “Men work together whether they work together or apart.” – Robert Frost.

What is the biggest paradox known?

Simpson’s paradox, also called Yule-Simpson effect, in statistics, an effect that occurs when the marginal association between two categorical variables is qualitatively different from the partial association between the same two variables after controlling for one or more other variables.Simpson’s paradox is important for three critical reasons.

What is the paradox of value and its solution?

The paradox of value (also known as the diamond–water paradox) is the contradiction that, although water is on the whole more useful, in terms of survival, than diamonds, diamonds command a higher price in the market.

What is paradox of value in economics example?

The Paradox of Value tells us that prices for goods are based on marginal utility rather than total utility. Example: Water gives us more total utility than diamonds (we need water to live), yet we are willing to pay a lot more for diamonds.

Who gave the concept of paradox of value?

2. Classical-Philosophical thoughts. The first to observe a paradoxical relationship between value and utility was Plato.

Why does the paradox of value between diamonds and water arise?

Clearly, water is more valuable as an essential resource as opposed to the luxury of owning a diamond. As demand increases as well, consumers must choose between one additional diamond versus one additional unit of water. This principle is known as marginal utility.

What is the meaning of paradox of value?

A term that describes the phenomenon of the market price of goods essential to life, like water, being way lower than that of goods that are non-essential, like diamonds.

What is the paradox of value quizlet?

Paradox of value refers to the: high value of a nonessential item and the low value of an essential item. A nation's wealth is determined by its: accumulation of all tangible products.

What is the value paradox business?

The paradox says that if we compete with our customers, to discover that which will provide them with value before they have discovered it themselves, we put our business in a competition from which the profitable rewards will only grow the more we compete.

What is a paradox economics?

Paradox in economics is the situation where the variables fail to follow the generally laid principles and assumptions of the theory and behave in an opposite fashion. Paradoxes are very common in economics.

Why is water less expensive than diamonds?

Luckily the supply of water is vast, meaning that it can be supplied at a very low price. Water is cheap at the margin, and therefore cheap to buy. But, the total utility of water is much higher than the total utility of diamonds. The difference is the quantity purchased and availability of supply.

How does Adam Smith explain the paradox of value?

Some of them such as Adam Smith, who was a proponent of the labor theory of value, believed that the paradox of value can be explained by the difference in the amount of labor that it takes to produce a good or service.

Why does the diamond-water paradox support the theory that prices reflect marginal utility not total utility?

Why does the diamond-water paradox support the theory that prices reflect marginal utility, not total utility? Total utility of water is high because water is useful. The total utility of diamonds is comparatively low because diamonds are not as useful as water.

What is the answer to the diamond-water paradox?

answer to the so-called “diamond-water paradox,” which economist Adam Smith pondered but was unable to solve. Smith noted that, even though life cannot exist without water and can easily exist without diamonds, diamonds are, pound for pound, vastly more valuable than water.

How do economists deal with the paradox of value?

Most modern economists deal with the paradox of value by attempting to unify these considerations under the concept of utility – or, how well something satisfies a person’s wants or needs.

Who wrote the paradox of value?

The paradox of value is famously described by pioneering economist Adam Smith. In his treatise An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), Smith writes:

What is the Principles of Economics?

Principles of Economics is a brilliant book for beginners to start learning about economics. The economic concepts covered in the lesson fall under the broad bucket of microeconomics which, in itself, is a sub-category of economics.

What is the diamond water paradox?

Also known as the diamond-water paradox. We understand that water is necessary to our life and that ornaments such as diamonds are not life-sustaining. But water typically has a low market price, while diamond jewellery has a high market price.

Why is the marginal utility of diamonds so high?

The marginal utility of a diamond is often very high in part because it is used as a celebration of a life-event and also as a signal from one person to another of their commitment to each other. Value in use i.e. drinking water to satisfy your thirst.

Why are paradoxes important?

As we learn to identify and handle paradoxes, we are able to master life further. Paradoxes are used as tools to help achieve enlightenment by monks following Eastern traditions.

Why are paradoxes used?

Paradoxes are used as tools to help achieve enlightenment by monks following Eastern traditions. By getting a handle on paradoxes, you'll be ahead of people who insist "well, which is? it can't be both!". Sometimes, as you will soon see, it can. Advertisement.

What is the Buddhist philosophy of paradoxical language?

Buddhist and Taoist literature offers practitioners paradoxical language as a way for them to free their minds from the constraints of standard logic. Everyday life is full of paradoxes, and these practices embrace and emphasize them on the path to liberation. Zen Koans make paradox meditation into an art form ...

What is paradoxical intervention?

Paradoxical interventions are psychological techniques which achieve the desired effect in a person's life but in an unexpected way. They are achieved, as an article notes in Psychology Today, by prescribing the same symptom which is considered undesirable. Someone who procrastinates is told to procrastinate intentionally. Fear of failure is met with a direction to fail intentionally. This approach helps the client understand the need which the symptom is meeting, and to reveal how much control the client has over the symptom.

Why is paradoxical behavior important?

Paradoxical behavior is an important factor as we set machines to learn about our behavior and anticipate it. In an Amerian Mathematical Society article, the paradox is described as behavior which doesn't match prior experience or expectations.

What is the paradox of freedom?

He presented the paradox of freedom as the necessity for freedom, the lack of "constraining control" to lead to a high degree of control because it eventually enables the bully to control the weak victim, removing freedom.

What are some examples of paradoxes in management?

A basic example is the fact that employees are at the same time individuals and part of an organization. These are two conditions which exist at the same time and are mutually exclusive as definitions. By considering this duality, managers can try to understand the role of their workers more deeply and improve their handling of workers' lives at work without excluding one or the other perspective.

Why do paradoxes occur?

Paradoxes are named; we decide to call certain things paradoxes; One way we describe our confusion is by calling things paradoxes; Taken together these make the answer obvious: paradoxes occur around the boundary of our understanding because ‘paradox’ is the name for the boundary.

What is paradox in science?

Paradoxes are apparent inconsistencies. That word, “apparent”, means that they seem inconsistent, but actually aren’t, and the reason is that our intuitions are not 100% foolproof all the. Continue Reading. Paradoxes are the prime example of the child’s answer to:

Why do other paradoxes seem like paradoxes?

They either only seem like a paradox because we do not have enough knowledge to explain them or that are true paradoxes, or in other words: impossible. 182 views · Answer requested by. Quora User.

What does the paradox say about killing your grandfather?

The paradox states that, if a person was to go back in time and kill his own grandfather before he met his grandmother, then , that person should cease to exist. But wait, if he doesn’t exist…. Who killed his grandfather in the first place?

What is the distance paradox?

The distance paradox which states that hypothetically speaking, one can never travel the distance between point A and Point B. For, he has to travel at least half the distance between point A and point B and once he's done that, he has to travel half of the distance that's left. Therefore, one will always remain some distance far from B.

What does Kierkegaard mean by "without the paradox"?

Kierkegaard said that we must not think ill of the paradox, for the paradox is the passion of thought, and the thinker without the paradox is like the lover without passion: a mediocre fellow. He postulated that the very essence of a paradox in thought is to think of something or come up with something that e.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
8.3.21PHP Version3.51sRequest Duration2MBMemory UsageGET {post}Route
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\QueryFormatter:...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\QueryFormatter:...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: Callables of the form ["Swift_SmtpTransport", "Swift_Transport_EsmtpTranspor...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\SimpleFormatter...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\SimpleFormatter...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • warninglog[06:12:17] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • Booting (13.71ms)
  • Application (3.5s)
  • 1 x Application (99.6%)
    3.50s
    1 x Booting (0.39%)
    13.71ms
    7 templates were rendered
    • themes.DevBlog.content.post (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/content/post.blade.php)34blade
      Params
      0
      post
      1
      postContent
      2
      author
      3
      updated_at
      4
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      5
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      6
      bing_related_keywords
      7
      google_related_keywords
      8
      bing_news_title
      9
      bing_news_description
      10
      bing_videos
      11
      bing_images
      12
      bing_search_result_title
      13
      bing_search_result_description
      14
      bing_search_result_url
      15
      bing_paa_questions
      16
      bing_paa_answers
      17
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      18
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      19
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      20
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      21
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      22
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      23
      google_faq_questions
      24
      google_faq_answers
      25
      google_rich_snippet
      26
      google_search_result
      27
      indexedArray
      28
      total_images
      29
      total_videos
      30
      settings
      31
      url_current
      32
      menus
      33
      sidebar
    • themes.DevBlog.layouts.master (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/layouts/master.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.head (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/head.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.header (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/header.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.navbar (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/navbar.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.footer (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/footer.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.scripts (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/scripts.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    uri
    GET {post}
    middleware
    web, checkdate
    as
    post.show
    controller
    App\Http\Controllers\Frontend\json_data\PostController@show
    namespace
    where
    file
    app/Http/Controllers/Frontend/json_data/PostController.php:18-166
    7 statements were executed3.48s
    • select * from `posts` where `published_at` <= '2025-06-08 06:12:17' and `slug` = 'why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist' and `posts`.`deleted_at` is null limit 1
      3.79ms/app/Providers/RouteServiceProvider.php:54receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 2025-06-08 06:12:17
      • 1. why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist
      Backtrace
      • 15. /app/Providers/RouteServiceProvider.php:54
      • 18. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Router.php:842
      • 19. Route binding:39
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 21. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/Http/Middleware/VerifyCsrfToken.php:78
    • select * from `json_post_contents` where `json_post_contents`.`post_id` = 217643 and `json_post_contents`.`post_id` is not null and `rewrite_id` = 0
      7.63msmiddleware::checkdate:30receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 217643
      • 1. 0
      Backtrace
      • 19. middleware::checkdate:30
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 21. /vendor/laravel/jetstream/src/Http/Middleware/ShareInertiaData.php:61
      • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Middleware/SubstituteBindings.php:50
    • select * from `nova_menu_menus` where `slug` = 'header' limit 1
      1.19ms/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:32receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. header
      Backtrace
      • 15. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:32
      • 17. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 18. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 19. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
    • select * from `nova_menu_menu_items` where `nova_menu_menu_items`.`menu_id` = 1 and `nova_menu_menu_items`.`menu_id` is not null and `parent_id` is null order by `parent_id` asc, `order` asc, `name` asc
      840μs/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 1
      Backtrace
      • 19. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35
      • 20. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:33
      • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
    • select * from `nova_menu_menu_items` where `nova_menu_menu_items`.`parent_id` in (1) order by `order` asc
      640μs/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Backtrace
      • 24. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35
      • 25. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:33
      • 27. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 28. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 29. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
    • select `id`, `post_title`, `slug` from `posts` where `status` = 'publish' and `posts`.`deleted_at` is null order by RAND() limit 10
      3.46s/app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:22receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. publish
      Backtrace
      • 14. /app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:22
      • 15. /app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:12
      • 16. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:124
      • 17. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:162
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:177
    • select * from `fake_users` where `fake_users`.`id` = 12387 limit 1
      860μsview::2dd102cf0462e89a4d4d8bc77355d767652bf9aa:15receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 12387
      Backtrace
      • 21. view::2dd102cf0462e89a4d4d8bc77355d767652bf9aa:15
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:108
      • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/PhpEngine.php:58
      • 25. /vendor/livewire/livewire/src/ComponentConcerns/RendersLivewireComponents.php:69
      • 26. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:61
    App\Models\FakeUser
    1
    Outl1ne\MenuBuilder\Models\MenuItem
    1
    Outl1ne\MenuBuilder\Models\Menu
    1
    App\Models\JsonPostContent
    1
    App\Models\Post
    11
        _token
        majFTfmUkTfUMxoNaGKNloUYzCkBsMUwuJcFPLC2
        _previous
        array:1 [ "url" => "https://receivinghelpdesk.com/ask/why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist" ]
        _flash
        array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ]
        PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA
        []
        path_info
        /why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist
        status_code
        200
        
        status_text
        OK
        format
        html
        content_type
        text/html; charset=UTF-8
        request_query
        []
        
        request_request
        []
        
        request_headers
        0 of 0
        array:25 [ "cookie" => array:1 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ind4MjBkODNQYnFpR1FXcnRJMTEwanc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibUtqWmRHZmRsbWM1elh3Vmgzc2ZGSFR6MHFLNFNWYUpNc1lMU0Rhd29RYzRSODQwLzRueWJreDhUYllxVWdPWkRQMVNkYWMxc0t1NjgyZ1M5Skczc3Jha0M0Sy9mZzArN0U2M21zSU0rWEp6eFhNWWwxRVNmZFEvRDlKZGcxSkkiLCJtYWMiOiIzNjUyZTNjYzI4YmRlZDQ5MTE5MmE5ZWZjOTg2ZGI0Njc4ZTI3MGNjMzVhNGMxMmRkYTQ2MGJhM2RmMWRhMjM2IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IlR5dzNqY3IzSHZnMDRrNjJZUExIL3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZmZmSHM5ZDFNSzF5VjNkcDF3VVpBWEp1cTVVSWZvY09FZVlkakJlcXBlcDF3ZWx5dUo1dytFWFNIdFdLOVcwSngxcXF4bUZUQnNpMWZIR1ppd0R4eldZTTg3R1FPWFM4cDBkU21BZUpXVld6RERVZnFydGlBVWN0Rm1vWVdaVWgiLCJtYWMiOiJkMzQyYTc0MTQ4ZGFjNDk3OTJjZGM4OWYyOGI0NzA1M2IwNmY1ZTcwMDQ0MDZmOGYxZGQ5MWYxODVlOTBjOTY4IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; _pk_id.64.7c30=629de7d74a83b6a8.1749343336.; _pk_ses.64.7c30=1XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ind4MjBkODNQYnFpR1FXcnRJMTEwanc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibUtqWmRHZmRsbWM1elh3Vmgzc2ZGSFR6MHFLNFNWYUpNc1lMU0Rhd29RYzRSODQwLzRueWJreDhUYllxVWdPWkRQMVNkY" ] "cf-ipcountry" => array:1 [ 0 => "US" ] "cf-connecting-ip" => array:1 [ 0 => "216.73.216.214" ] "cdn-loop" => array:1 [ 0 => "cloudflare; loops=1" ] "sec-fetch-mode" => array:1 [ 0 => "navigate" ] "sec-fetch-site" => array:1 [ 0 => "none" ] "accept" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" ] "user-agent" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" ] "upgrade-insecure-requests" => array:1 [ 0 => "1" ] "sec-ch-ua-platform" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Windows"" ] "sec-ch-ua-mobile" => array:1 [ 0 => "?0" ] "sec-ch-ua" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Chromium";v="130", "HeadlessChrome";v="130", "Not?A_Brand";v="99"" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "accept-encoding" => array:1 [ 0 => "gzip, br" ] "cf-ray" => array:1 [ 0 => "94c45935ec21eafd-ORD" ] "priority" => array:1 [ 0 => "u=0, i" ] "sec-fetch-dest" => array:1 [ 0 => "document" ] "sec-fetch-user" => array:1 [ 0 => "?1" ] "cf-visitor" => array:1 [ 0 => "{"scheme":"https"}" ] "connection" => array:1 [ 0 => "close" ] "x-forwarded-proto" => array:1 [ 0 => "https" ] "x-forwarded-for" => array:1 [ 0 => "216.73.216.214, 172.71.254.174" ] "x-server-addr" => array:1 [ 0 => "154.12.239.204" ] "host" => array:1 [ 0 => "receivinghelpdesk.com" ] ]
        request_server
        0 of 0
        array:56 [ "USER" => "runcloud" "HOME" => "/home/runcloud" "SCRIPT_NAME" => "/ask/index.php" "REQUEST_URI" => "/ask/why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist" "QUERY_STRING" => "" "REQUEST_METHOD" => "GET" "SERVER_PROTOCOL" => "HTTP/1.0" "GATEWAY_INTERFACE" => "CGI/1.1" "REDIRECT_URL" => "/ask/why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist" "REMOTE_PORT" => "41526" "SCRIPT_FILENAME" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/ask/index.php" "SERVER_ADMIN" => "you@example.com" "CONTEXT_DOCUMENT_ROOT" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/" "CONTEXT_PREFIX" => "" "REQUEST_SCHEME" => "http" "DOCUMENT_ROOT" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/" "REMOTE_ADDR" => "172.71.254.174" "SERVER_PORT" => "80" "SERVER_ADDR" => "127.0.0.1" "SERVER_NAME" => "receivinghelpdesk.com" "SERVER_SOFTWARE" => "Apache/2.4.63 (Unix) OpenSSL/1.1.1f" "SERVER_SIGNATURE" => "" "LD_LIBRARY_PATH" => "/RunCloud/Packages/apache2-rc/lib" "PATH" => "/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin" "HTTP_COOKIE" => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ind4MjBkODNQYnFpR1FXcnRJMTEwanc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibUtqWmRHZmRsbWM1elh3Vmgzc2ZGSFR6MHFLNFNWYUpNc1lMU0Rhd29RYzRSODQwLzRueWJreDhUYllxVWdPWkRQMVNkYWMxc0t1NjgyZ1M5Skczc3Jha0M0Sy9mZzArN0U2M21zSU0rWEp6eFhNWWwxRVNmZFEvRDlKZGcxSkkiLCJtYWMiOiIzNjUyZTNjYzI4YmRlZDQ5MTE5MmE5ZWZjOTg2ZGI0Njc4ZTI3MGNjMzVhNGMxMmRkYTQ2MGJhM2RmMWRhMjM2IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IlR5dzNqY3IzSHZnMDRrNjJZUExIL3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZmZmSHM5ZDFNSzF5VjNkcDF3VVpBWEp1cTVVSWZvY09FZVlkakJlcXBlcDF3ZWx5dUo1dytFWFNIdFdLOVcwSngxcXF4bUZUQnNpMWZIR1ppd0R4eldZTTg3R1FPWFM4cDBkU21BZUpXVld6RERVZnFydGlBVWN0Rm1vWVdaVWgiLCJtYWMiOiJkMzQyYTc0MTQ4ZGFjNDk3OTJjZGM4OWYyOGI0NzA1M2IwNmY1ZTcwMDQ0MDZmOGYxZGQ5MWYxODVlOTBjOTY4IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; _pk_id.64.7c30=629de7d74a83b6a8.1749343336.; _pk_ses.64.7c30=1XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ind4MjBkODNQYnFpR1FXcnRJMTEwanc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibUtqWmRHZmRsbWM1elh3Vmgzc2ZGSFR6MHFLNFNWYUpNc1lMU0Rhd29RYzRSODQwLzRueWJreDhUYllxVWdPWkRQMVNkY" "HTTP_CF_IPCOUNTRY" => "US" "HTTP_CF_CONNECTING_IP" => "216.73.216.214" "HTTP_CDN_LOOP" => "cloudflare; loops=1" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_MODE" => "navigate" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_SITE" => "none" "HTTP_ACCEPT" => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" "HTTP_USER_AGENT" => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" "HTTP_UPGRADE_INSECURE_REQUESTS" => "1" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_PLATFORM" => ""Windows"" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_MOBILE" => "?0" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA" => ""Chromium";v="130", "HeadlessChrome";v="130", "Not?A_Brand";v="99"" "HTTP_CACHE_CONTROL" => "no-cache" "HTTP_PRAGMA" => "no-cache" "HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING" => "gzip, br" "HTTP_CF_RAY" => "94c45935ec21eafd-ORD" "HTTP_PRIORITY" => "u=0, i" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_DEST" => "document" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_USER" => "?1" "HTTP_CF_VISITOR" => "{"scheme":"https"}" "HTTP_CONNECTION" => "close" "HTTP_X_FORWARDED_PROTO" => "https" "HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR" => "216.73.216.214, 172.71.254.174" "HTTP_X_SERVER_ADDR" => "154.12.239.204" "HTTP_HOST" => "receivinghelpdesk.com" "HTTPS" => "on" "REDIRECT_STATUS" => "200" "REDIRECT_HTTPS" => "on" "FCGI_ROLE" => "RESPONDER" "PHP_SELF" => "/ask/index.php" "REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT" => 1749343337.9183 "REQUEST_TIME" => 1749343337 ]
        request_cookies
        0 of 0
        array:4 [ "XSRF-TOKEN" => "majFTfmUkTfUMxoNaGKNloUYzCkBsMUwuJcFPLC2" "askhelpdesk_session" => "DGVv7B0EL5IClffzNYeKYfaMIZ7n4UhmUsS5vtYX" "_pk_id_64_7c30" => null "_pk_ses_64_7c30" => null ]
        response_headers
        0 of 0
        array:7 [ "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html; charset=UTF-8" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "private, must-revalidate" ] "date" => array:1 [ 0 => "Sun, 08 Jun 2025 00:42:17 GMT" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "expires" => array:1 [ 0 => -1 ] "set-cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6IkowNURGaURrWmIxdU4wVlBRSDNLUUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibWZkdUg3cGJ6V0lqKzBlT21ocUpMWGVOaXVBWTdtSFYvd1BJZ1ZxSXlKelV0R3VwZ0dldWhERWg2QTVzclUrM3h3QitLR3V6dUxNd015MWRwVERPT3RYRlVpaURRVXlpTFdXV3NzNFFDc1lrdDNyOTAyR3BadTBjNkl2MXhGMDUiLCJtYWMiOiJlODZlMDE5MzEyYjkwMmU5OTJmM2ZlZDgwMzc5OWVjN2RjZmQzNGYyMDUyMTQ0YzNiMjIyYjJlY2NmOTBjNmVkIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sun, 08-Jun-2025 02:42:21 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; samesite=laxXSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6IkowNURGaURrWmIxdU4wVlBRSDNLUUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibWZkdUg3cGJ6V0lqKzBlT21ocUpMWGVOaXVBWTdtSFYvd1BJZ1ZxSXlKelV0R3VwZ0dldWhERWg2QTVzclUrM3h3QitLR" 1 => "askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IjhzaUFJNTJHbDVtUmZhWVJTWmhLWXc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVk8zWklta1ZBOGJkN29CMnF3NExMdnA5VzNNWnkwVHp2RHlMMEdrT2FyMGJpWVJMRnhXeWhMVjJzWWJuMXh6NFR3RjJ5L1lCbU1pK2kzTFk3alpzU05YTnl2bkRQOUxIenV4WUNZZVZwd1VwMHlTcUZVMUFJa242bmhxNnFXSTIiLCJtYWMiOiIwZmQ4ODk2Zjc5YzM5NjIwNjM5M2ZiZTMzZGFiZmQ2MmMwMmIxNzg1NTgzOWVjZDM4NzQxODg5YWM3YWFlY2RhIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sun, 08-Jun-2025 02:42:21 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; httponly; samesite=laxaskhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IjhzaUFJNTJHbDVtUmZhWVJTWmhLWXc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVk8zWklta1ZBOGJkN29CMnF3NExMdnA5VzNNWnkwVHp2RHlMMEdrT2FyMGJpWVJMRnhXeWhMVjJzWWJuMXh6" ] "Set-Cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6IkowNURGaURrWmIxdU4wVlBRSDNLUUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibWZkdUg3cGJ6V0lqKzBlT21ocUpMWGVOaXVBWTdtSFYvd1BJZ1ZxSXlKelV0R3VwZ0dldWhERWg2QTVzclUrM3h3QitLR3V6dUxNd015MWRwVERPT3RYRlVpaURRVXlpTFdXV3NzNFFDc1lrdDNyOTAyR3BadTBjNkl2MXhGMDUiLCJtYWMiOiJlODZlMDE5MzEyYjkwMmU5OTJmM2ZlZDgwMzc5OWVjN2RjZmQzNGYyMDUyMTQ0YzNiMjIyYjJlY2NmOTBjNmVkIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sun, 08-Jun-2025 02:42:21 GMT; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6IkowNURGaURrWmIxdU4wVlBRSDNLUUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoibWZkdUg3cGJ6V0lqKzBlT21ocUpMWGVOaXVBWTdtSFYvd1BJZ1ZxSXlKelV0R3VwZ0dldWhERWg2QTVzclUrM3h3QitLR" 1 => "askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IjhzaUFJNTJHbDVtUmZhWVJTWmhLWXc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVk8zWklta1ZBOGJkN29CMnF3NExMdnA5VzNNWnkwVHp2RHlMMEdrT2FyMGJpWVJMRnhXeWhMVjJzWWJuMXh6NFR3RjJ5L1lCbU1pK2kzTFk3alpzU05YTnl2bkRQOUxIenV4WUNZZVZwd1VwMHlTcUZVMUFJa242bmhxNnFXSTIiLCJtYWMiOiIwZmQ4ODk2Zjc5YzM5NjIwNjM5M2ZiZTMzZGFiZmQ2MmMwMmIxNzg1NTgzOWVjZDM4NzQxODg5YWM3YWFlY2RhIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sun, 08-Jun-2025 02:42:21 GMT; path=/; httponlyaskhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IjhzaUFJNTJHbDVtUmZhWVJTWmhLWXc9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVk8zWklta1ZBOGJkN29CMnF3NExMdnA5VzNNWnkwVHp2RHlMMEdrT2FyMGJpWVJMRnhXeWhMVjJzWWJuMXh6" ] ]
        session_attributes
        0 of 0
        array:4 [ "_token" => "majFTfmUkTfUMxoNaGKNloUYzCkBsMUwuJcFPLC2" "_previous" => array:1 [ "url" => "https://receivinghelpdesk.com/ask/why-does-the-paradox-of-value-exist" ] "_flash" => array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ] "PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA" => [] ]