which is better hog ring or detent pin

by Mozelle Dare Published 3 years ago Updated 3 years ago

Detent Pin vs Hog Ring: Detailed Comparison Guide

Durability. First, if we compare the durability of both anvils, then we can see that the detent pin is more durable than the hog ring.
Stability. According to consumers, the stability of the hog ring is much more elevated, especially if it can be combined in a remarkable way against the balance of the sockets.
Switchability. ...
Maintenance. ...
Safety. ...

In these applications, the detent pin will prevent the socket from falling out unexpectedly. The hog ring anvil is used by those who need to quickly change, such as a mechanic.Nov 11, 2020

Full Answer

What is the difference between a detent pin and hog ring?

A detent pin is much more durable than a hog ring. Not as hog ring. A little bit hard to put and release any sockets. Same as a hog ring. The release point of the detent pin is very strong, that’s why it is very secure. In this section, we will discuss the differences between both detent pin and hog ring in detail. Let’s see.

What are the advantages of a hog ring?

One of the most useful advantages of the hog ring is that you can easily set and release any sockets with just a little bit of pressure. So if you always work with different sizes of sockets, bolts, then a hog ring is a great option, which saves your time and effort.

Which is better hog ring or detent anvil?

Which is better hog ring or detent pin? A detent anvil retains the socket with a spring-loaded ball like on ratchets. A hog ring anvil retains the socket with a steel ring in a groove on the square drive, as on most air impact wrenches. The hog ring anvil tends to be more ornery to fit sockets onto and off from, but also retains them better.

Should I get a hog ring or a driver?

Properly used you're basically guaranteed to need a driver to push the pin in for socket removal. Hog ring is for decent socket retention with ease of swapping. I vote hog ring. More sharing options...

What is better pin detent or friction ring?

Removal Comparison

A friction ring is a better choice than detent pins concerning removal features. It is quite simple to remove the socket's friction ring; you can remove it any time by applying little force. Simple switch off the drill when properly stop, pull the friction ring and detach it from the socket.Mar 11, 2021

Is a hog ring better?

A hog ring anvil retains the socket with a steel ring in a groove on the square drive, as on most air impact wrenches. The hog ring anvil tends to be more ornery to fit sockets onto and off from, but also retains them better.

Do you need special sockets for hog ring?

You don't need a special socket for the hog ring to hold tight.

What does a hog ring do?

Hog rings are C- or D-shaped fasteners used to connect wire fencing, close mesh or fabric bags, or attach fabric and other materials in furniture manufacturing.

What is a square drive hog ring?

A hog ring (also known as a friction ring) uses a circular ring around the square end of the driver to hold the socket in place. A detent pin uses a spring loaded ball bearing on one side of the square end of the driver to hold the socket in place.

What is the difference between 1 2 and 3/8 impact wrench?

A 1/2 impact wrench has a more powerful motor and a bigger battery to give power to it, which adds to the overall weight compared to its 3/8 counterpart. In fact, it's pretty common to find 1/2 impact drivers weighing around 7 pounds while 3/8 impact wrenches weigh approximately 2 lbs (less than half).Oct 22, 2021

When should you not use an impact gun?

When Not to Use an Impact Driver? 5 Situations

Non-Hex Shank Bits. Impact drivers are very useful tools indeed, but something that does need to be said about them is that the special mechanism they use for their bits only accepts hex-shaped bits. ...
Short Screws. ...
Soft Materials. ...
Precision Work. ...
Drilling Holes.

Jun 14, 2021

What is a detent pin?

Detent pins, also known as cotterless hitch pins or quick release pins, are designed for temporary quick disconnect operations or any application that requires rapid, frequent, and manual assembly and disassembly of a particular object.

Why do impact sockets have a hole?

That hole has a very specific purpose. It's called a retaining pin and it is integral in making sure an impact socket and impact gun/wrench work perfectly together. The pin prevents the socket from coming off the end of the wrench or gun as a result of vibrations.Apr 9, 2020

Why do they put rings in pigs nose?

Nose rings are used on pigs to discourage rooting. Some nose rings are installed through a pierced hole in the nasal septum or rim of the nose and remain there, while others are temporary tools.

How are hog rings sized?

Hog Rings are measured from their endpoints at the widest points. D-type hog rings have a flat base, so their measurements are based upon the length of the hog ring. C-types and M-types are both measured at their farthest sides from each other. The measurements are given at sections of an inch.Dec 29, 2021

How do you put a ring in a pigs nose?

Putting a ring in a pig's nose is a two-person job. One person restrains the pig by catching it in a hog shoot and holds the pig's head steady. A second person uses nose ring pliers to position the ring on the top of the nose on the outside, then squeezes quickly to put the ring in place.Sep 26, 2017

Why use a hog ring?

The biggest benefit of the hog ring is the ease with which you can put the sockets and take them off. Definitely, this is the much easier way. So, if you need to often exchange the sockets to work with different size bolts, the hog ring saves time and effort. This is except when the pin is brand new and fresh – it will need to take some wear in order to get the sockets on and off more smoothly.

What is the benefit of hog rings?

The biggest benefit of the hog ring is the ease with which you can put the sockets and take it off. Definitely, this is the much easier way. So, if you need to often exchange the sockets to work with different size bolts, the hog ring saves time and effort.

What is impact wrench with detent pin?

Impact Wrench with Detent Pin. In detent pin anvils, the pin goes out from the side of the anvil and it’s regulated by a spring. Once you put the socket, two things can happen: the pin is the one that gives friction to the socket, but to a much lesser extent compared to the hog ring. Or, you can match the pin with a round hole on the socket, ...

Why is an anvil the most durable part of a gear?

So, an anvil has to be the sturdiest and the most durable part of the gear, because it takes the force of the motor on one side, and the friction and resistance of screws and bolts on the other side. It also needs to keep the sockets securely and firmly, not letting them loose before the time is right.

Do you need to replace hog rings?

Other than the anvils, the hog ring and detent pin parts can be worn off over time and you’d need to replace them eventually. Both anvils contain a spring that pushes both the pin and the ring in its place, so replacing them can be tricky.

Can you use a hog ring without a spring?

The benefits of the hog ring without the spring are obvious – aside from the anvil, the pin is the only part. The downside is that once it shrinks to a certain degree, it won’t hold anymore, and needs a switch.

Can you replace an anvil pin?

Don’t worry, if the anvils take too much damage, they too can be replaced. Other than the anvils, the hog ring and detent pin parts can be worn off over time and you’d need to replace them eventually. Both anvils contain a spring that pushes both the pin and the ring in its place, so replacing them can be tricky.

What is a hog ring?

1 : a split metal ring usually with beveled points that can be pushed through the median cartilage of the nose of a pig and there locked to prevent rooting or to serve as a means of leading the animal. 2 : an upholstery fastener resembling a hog ring.

What is the difference between a detent anvil and a hog ring anvil?

A detent anvil retains the socket with a spring-loaded ball like on ratchets. A hog ring anvil retains the socket with a steel ring in a groove on the square drive, as on most air impact wrenches. The hog ring anvil tends to be more ornery to fit sockets onto and off from , but also retains them better. Click to see full answer.

Hog Ring Anvil

A hog ring anvil is the type of impact driver but has slight differences in the working mechanism as well that you will need to be particularly careful about since you cannot use a Hog Ring Anvil from DeWalt as the replacement for your impact driver.

Detent Pin

Detent pin is quite a similar tool, and a person who doesn’t have much experience of working with such tools might not be able to differentiate between these two either.

What is the difference between a hog ring anvil and a detent pin anvil?

What is the difference in a hog ring anvil and detent pin anvil on an impact wrench? A detent pin anvil has a retaining pin that must be pressed in to release a socket from the impact driver. A hog ring anvil has a ring that exerts pressure on the socket and can be removed without tools (or with bare hands).

What is hog ring anvil?

The hog ring anvil is used by those who need to quickly change, such as a mechanic. The mechanic working on a vehicle will need to quickly change out the sockets without the extra step of using another tool to release the socket from the anvil. In this application, it's usually low to the ground, so a socket that falls out will not pose ...

What is the difference between a friction ring and a pin detent?

The pin detent holds the socket in place and is mostly for using one socket a lot. The friction ring is easier to remove and great for instances where you need to swap out sockets.

Why use a pin detent?

That said, there is something to be said about flexibility. Pin detents tend to offer less flexibility and make it more difficult to swap out sockets. When you need to move between sockets, using a pin detent can be a real hassle.

What are the downsides of friction rings?

The only downside to the friction rings is that they are not quite as durable and sturdy as detent rings. The rubber is susceptible to damage and tears, requiring the need to replace it before using the impact wrench again.

What is the difference between a pin and an impact wrench?

The difference here is that the pin tends to be a bit more secure and heavy-duty. It holds the socket quite tight to the impact wrench, providing a more secure connection than the friction ring and its rubber connector would. Pin detents are ideal for securing the socket into place.

What is the pros and cons of pin detents?

The biggest pro regarding the pin detents is the durability and stability offered. Remember that impact wrenches are meant to be used in situations where lots of force is required. Having a sturdier connection to hold the socket in place is key.

Why use friction ring?

The reason for the friction ring has to do with removing the socket. Because it is less secure, it is ideal for swapping out multiple sockets.

What is the ball that goes into the hole in a detent?

When the detent is installed, there is a spring-loaded ball that projects out of the pin shaft. That ball that goes into the hole or detent and locks the pin into place. Removing the pin can only happen when the user pusses the designated button at the top, releasing the pin.

What is a friction ring impact wrench?

Friction ring impact wrench can be considered as regular or hog ring impact wrench. There is a lock ring end of the collet. Normally most of the tools consist of the friction ring rather than pin detent. The friction ring is with a square collet, and it has fully designed to mount the socket.

Is there a price difference in friction ring?

Considering the price, there is no high price difference in the friction ring or pin detent. There is an affordable price for the user.

Is a friction ring safe?

The friction ring is the general collet, as I described above. It will not have an additional force to mount or remove the socket. Due to this, it is a bit unsafe. When the collet is rotating, it can throw away due to removing from the collet. So think about safety before you buy both.

Can you use a pin detent impact wrench with a friction ring?

The friction ring impact wrench is easy and comfortable to insert into the collet, but less safety and pin detent is tight to insert, but it is safer. If you use many sockets in a day friction ring is good for you and 1-2 sockets per day you can use a pin detent impact wrench.