Receiving Helpdesk

whats the difference between mexican vanilla and regular vanilla

by Evert Romaguera II Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

Pure vanilla is made with the extract of beans from the vanilla plant. Mexican vanilla is frequently made with the extract of beans from the tonka tree, an entirely different plant that belongs to the pea family. Tonka bean extract contains coumarin.Oct 31, 2008

What is the best Mexican vanilla to buy?

Simply Organic Pure Vanilla Extract

  • Good value per ounce if you buy in large format
  • Subtle but pleasing vanilla taste
  • Available at supermarkets and online

What makes Mexican vanilla different?

What Makes a Fragrances Last Long?

  • Concentration. ...
  • Fragrance Notes. ...
  • Skin Chemistry. ...
  • Eau de Cologne (2-5% concentration, lasts up to two hours.)
  • Eau de Toilette (5-15% concentration, lasts up to three hours.)
  • Eau de Parfum (15-20% concentration, lasts up to five hours.)

More items...

What are the ingredients in Mexican vanilla?

Mexican vanilla is frequently made with the extract of beans from the tonka tree, an entirely different plant that belongs to the pea family. Tonka bean extract contains coumarin.

Is Mexican vanilla safe to use?

While there may be some perfectly good and safe vanilla made in Mexico, unfortunately there are others that are not safe and shouldn't be used. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration one ingredient that is used in making so-called vanilla flavoring is the bean of the Tonka plant (Dipteryx odorata, also known as Coumarouna odorata).

Is Mexican vanilla stronger than regular vanilla?

Mexican Vanilla Its 2 or 4 times stronger and cheaper than other vanillas. The translation of the label says it is made with real vanilla.” We know you don't want to hear this, but it's either completely fake or contains very little real vanilla.

Can I use Mexican vanilla instead of vanilla extract?

Check labels to find Mexican vanilla that is processed in the United States and is guaranteed pure; this type is safe and can be substituted for regular vanilla.

Is Mexican vanilla better than vanilla extract?

According to US FDA regulations, in order to be labeled “pure” a vanilla extract must have 35% alcohol (FDA 21CFR169. 3). Our Pure Mexican vanilla contains this higher 35% alcohol content, and is therefore best utilized in those items which require high heat, such as baking. This allows much of the alcohol to cook out.

Is vanilla from Mexico real vanilla?

Mexican vanilla that is produced by a reputable American company is pure vanilla extract made from Mexican beans. Unfortunately, some specialty food stores carry Mexican vanilla made in Mexico. While it is possible that it is pure vanilla, the chances are more than 99% that it is not pure.

Is Mexican vanilla any good?

Nov. 1 -- FRIDAY, Oct. 31 (HealthDay News) -- So-called Mexican "vanilla" is often made with a toxic substance called coumarin and shouldn't be bought by consumers, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration warned this week. Coumarin is related to warfarin, which is found in some blood thinners.

Does Mexican vanilla tastes like cinnamon?

This product has a distinct cinnamon flavor to you. Some seem to have classified that was a "deep" or "exotic" vanilla flavor, but it's not; it's a simple cinnamon flavor.

What should I look for when buying Mexican vanilla?

How to Buy Mexican VanillaBuy coumarin-free vanilla. Coumarin is derived from the Brazilian tonka bean. ... Look for amber-colored vanilla. ... Avoid bargain vanilla sold in big marketplaces in Mexico and tourist shops. ... Check the alcohol content on the label. ... Buy vanilla from a reputable source.

Is Molina Mexican vanilla blend the same as vanilla extract?

Love this Molina Mexican Vanillan! Tastes better and costs much less than "vanilla extract!" Apparently vanilla is actually native to Mexico. And "vanillan" is made from the scraped vanilla pods used for making "vanilla extract," and "imitation vanilla" is made from tree bark and chemicals.

Which is better Mexican or Madagascar vanilla?

Madagascar vanilla Also called bourbon vanilla, Madagascan vanilla comes from the same plant and has the same basic flavor notes as Mexican vanilla. The only significant difference is that in Mexico, the plant is pollinated by a bee and in Madagascar, humans need to pollinate the flower, leading to its higher price.

What is the flavor of Mexican vanilla?

A rich marriage of sweet and woody notes, the Mexican vanilla flavor profile has a deep, creamy, spicy-sweet character, similar to clove or nutmeg. Mexican Pure Vanilla Extract's unique flavor profile means it works especially well with chocolate, citrus fruits, cinnamon, cloves and other warm spices.

Can I bring vanilla extract from Mexico to us?

The short answer is that unless you are bringing back cases and cases of vanilla, you won't have to pay duty but you do have to declare it.

Where is the best vanilla from?

Combined with the hot, humid climate and rich soil, hand pollination by the country's skilled and patient farmers has enabled Madagascar to become the world's top vanilla producer in both quantity and quality.

What is the difference between Madagascar vanilla and Mexican vanilla?

Regarded as the world's best, Madagascar beans set the standard for prime vanilla flavor. Mexican beans, while similar to Madagascar, have a darker flavor that is perfect for vanilla liqueur and coffee drinks.

How many ounces of vanilla beans are needed to make vanilla extract?

To make vanilla extract you need 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans, 35% alcohol and water.

How long does it take for Mexican vanilla to cure?

It is in this last stage that mexican vanilla differs most significantly--whereas vanilla from Madagascar may take about 5 weeks, Mexican vanilla will cure for several months. Real Vanilla, Is picked then smoke dried.

Where is vanilla orchid grown?

Vanilla planifolia is usually marketed as "Bourbon vanilla", most of which is grown in Indonesia and Madagascar. The same species is also grown in Mexico, ...

Why is vanilla heated?

First, vanilla is heated to kill the pod to prevent sugar from turning to starch, and to break down cell walls.

Where do vanilla beans come from?

All the vanilla beans cultivated around the world come from MEXICO and where transplanted to Madagascar, Indonesia, Reunion, Tonga, Costa Rica, Papua New Guinea, Reunion, etc, etc. They go by the name Vanilla Planifolia but it's really "Mansa" meaning "Domesticated" in Spanish.

Is vanilla a food additive?

At least the Mexicans claim their vanilla to be of superior quality, but the vanilla extracts sold in Mexico are often stretched with tonka bean extract, which has a similar taste and aroma to vanilla, but contains coumarin, which is banned as a food additive by the US Food & Drug Administration.

What is the difference between traditional vanilla and pure vanilla?

The primary difference between the Traditional and the Pure is the amount of alcohol in the vanilla. According to US FDA regulations, in order to be labeled “pure” a vanilla extract must have 35% alcohol ( FDA 21CFR169.3 ). Our Pure Mexican vanilla contains this higher 35% alcohol content, and is therefore best utilized in those items which require ...

What is Mexican vanilla used for?

Also the less alcohol makes the vanilla much more versatile. The Traditional Mexican vanilla can be used for anything that calls for vanilla; anything from french toast, smoothies, homemade ice cream, whip cream, cookies, cakes, oatmeal, etc, etc.

How much alcohol is in vanilla?

It has 10% alcohol and a small amount (less than 1%) of vanillin (which is a naturally occurring vanillin, not synthetic). The vanillin helps hold the flavor and gives the vanilla a very rich, smooth flavor. Also the less alcohol makes the vanilla much more versatile.

Where are Mexican vanilla beans made?

This allows much of the alcohol to cook out. Both the Traditional & Pure Mexican Vanillas are all natural, produced in Mexico using only the highest grade, single sourced, Mexican vanilla beans. Our Mexi can vanilla is never blended with another grade or type of bean – it is the absolute best vanilla available in Mexico.

How many types of vanilla are there?

There are over 150 types of vanilla in the world, including Indian vanilla, Tonga vanilla, and Ugandan vanilla —but the two most prevalent types found in most stores are Madagascar or bourbon vanilla, and Tahitian vanilla. Also worth a look: Mexican vanilla, as it’s made from the very same plant as bourbon vanilla, and Mexico is, in fact, the birthplace of vanilla.

Where is Mexican vanilla grown?

According to Michel Mustiere, Culinary Director of Velas Resorts, with multiple locations throughout Mexico, Mexican vanilla is cultivated in Veracruz, Mexico, and is the product of an orchid that gives birth to the vanilla flower after pollination.

Why is Tahiti called Vanilla Island?

In the Pacific Ocean, there is an island in Tahiti that is referred to as “Vanilla Island.” It got its name because 80 percent of the country’s vanilla is produced there.

What are the notes of vanilla?

According to Mustiere, you can pick up all of these notes: “metallic, astringent, smoked, pungent, toasted, gritty, spiciness of tuberose, sweet, clove, black pepper, cinnamon, raisin, wood, wet earth, dry chili, cocoa, tamarind, sesame, and mold.” (So not dissimilar to tasting good wine .)

How long does vanilla pod dry?

The pod, he says, is then allowed to dry for 20 days, then undergoes a fermentation process.

Where does vanilla come from?

The vanilla orchid was initially brought from Mexico to the areas surrounding the Indian Ocean in the 1800s, and those lands now supply two-thirds of the world’s vanilla. Madagascar leads the pack, with Indonesia in second place (while Indonesian vanilla comes from the same plant, it is said to have a smokier aroma and taste than creamier, sweeter Madagascan and Mexican vanilla).

Can you buy vanilla beans?

You can also buy fresh vanilla beans and make our Vanilla Extract recipe (after steeping, dry the pods and add them to a jar of sugar to make vanilla sugar for baking and sweetening drinks—because you don’t want to let one iota of that precious flavor go to waste, no matter which variety you choose).

Is all vanilla the same? Is Mexican vanilla better?

In general, Mexican vanilla is more complex and aromatic, rather than sweet and creamy, which are the characteristics you get from some American varieties. Your preference will depend on whether you prefer a more sensitive flavor or something bolder.

Is Mexican vanilla stronger than regular vanilla?

No, not as strong. Because of their variety, Mexican vanilla beans are less aromatic and their taste is more complex. The difference isn’t huge, however; the flavor of Mexican vanilla is strongest when added at a ratio closer to the 1:1 ratio used for extracts than to the 1:4 or 2:1 ratio used for extracts and regular beans.

Is vanilla blend the same as extract?

Vanilla extract is a combination of vanilla beans and alcohol. The more vanilla that is used and the longer it’s left to interact with the beans, the stronger the flavor will be. Vanilla extract is a true extract, as opposed to imitation products; most brands use alcohol made from grain such as corn. However, if you want to avoid additives, stick with single ingredient vanilla extracts instead of blends.

How many ounces of vanilla bean are in a vanilla extract?

Alcohol Free Pure Vanilla Flavor (Ingredients: Water; Glycerin; Vanilla Bean Extractives) Most companies in the USA make this product with the same 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans as Vanilla Extract, but replace the alcohol with glycerin.

What is vanilla extract?

Vanilla Extract is defined by the FDA in CFR 21, part 169. It must be extracted from no less than 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon, in a minimum of 35% ethyl alcohol, with the remaining liquid being water. The addition of sugar, glycerin, or corn syrup is also allowed and is sometimes added to Vanilla Extract to mask the flavor of synthetic alcohol. The ethyl alcohol can come from many different sources such as corn, sugar, or made synthetically from natural gas and petroleum derivatives. Ask your supplier for the source of the alcohol in their vanilla. The alcohol in Singing Dog Vanilla products is derived from pure cane sugar.

What is singing dog vanilla?

Singing Dog Vanilla and a few other reputable vanilla suppliers have developed Natural Vanilla Flavor . Natural Vanilla Flavor is also sometimes called WONF ( W ith O ther N atural Fl avors). Natural Vanilla Flavor is made with real vanilla beans and augmented with other plant extracts to approximate the flavor of pure vanilla extract.

What color is vanilla cake frosting?

The color of these products varies from clear to dark brown depending on the amount of food coloring added. Cake decorators often purchase clear vanilla so they can add vanilla flavor to cake frosting. Some labels may say, “made from vanillin crystals”.

Can vanilla extract be called vanilla extract?

According to FDA rules, because this product does not contain at least 35% alcohol, it cannot be called Vanilla Extract. Glycerin can come from many animal or vegetable sources. Check with your vanilla supplier for details if you have allergies or other concerns.

Is vanilla extract cheap?

Actually, most of the available vanilla beans from Mexico are purchased by USA-based companies that make extract from them. Real Mexican vanilla extract is not cheap.

Is Mexican vanilla real?

We know you don’t want to hear this, but it’s either completely fake or contains very little real vanilla. Real Mexican Vanilla is rare and expensive. Mexico has not figured out how to somehow grow and extract vanilla for a fraction of the cost of every other vanilla-growing country on the planet. Regardless of what it says on the label in English, the FDA and USDA do not issue “Approved” logos. Actually, most of the available vanilla beans from Mexico are purchased by USA-based companies that make extract from them. Real Mexican vanilla extract is not cheap. Therefore, if it is inexpensive it is probably fake.

What is Mexican vanilla flavor?

Mexican vanilla extract is not the same as regular vanilla. It is made from beans that have been fermented and dried. This process gives it a unique flavor . Regular vanilla extract is made from vanilla beans that have been extracted and then refined. It does not have any additional flavors added to it.

What makes Mexican vanilla taste different?

Mexican vanilla is a type of vanilla extract that contains real vanilla beans from Mexico. It is used in many different recipes such as cookies, ice cream, cake, and other desserts. Regular vanilla is a synthetic flavor that is usually extracted from fermented corn syrup. It is cheaper than Mexican vanilla but does not taste as good.

Why is Mexican vanilla cheaper than other types?

Mexican vanilla is cheaper because it’s made from sugarcane instead of beans. Sugarcane is cheaper than beans. Also, Mexican vanilla is processed differently than other types. Beans are dried and ground into powder. Then, they’re mixed with alcohol and heated to get rid of any impurities. After that, the mixture is strained and bottled. Mexican vanilla is made in a similar way, but it doesn’t go through the drying process. Instead, it’s cooked down until it becomes syrup. This syrup is then filtered and bottled.

How should you store vanilla extract?

Vanilla extract should always be stored in a cool dry place away from direct sunlight. Keep it tightly sealed in a dark glass bottle. Store it in a refrigerator if possible.

How can you tell if Mexican vanilla is real?

Vanilla beans are used in many different dishes and desserts around the world. It is usually added to baked goods such as breads, cookies, muffins, pies, cakes, waffles, pancakes, ice cream, custards, sauces, soups, stews, and other savory dishes. Vanilla beans are available in two forms: whole and ground. Whole vanilla beans are long, slender pods containing seeds. Ground vanilla is produced from dried vanilla beans. Both types of vanilla beans are available in varying degrees of quality. The best way to determine if a bean is good is to smell it. If it smells sweet and fragrant, it is probably good. If not, it is likely to be inferior.

Can you substitute Mexican vanilla for vanilla?

It is usually darker in color and has a stronger flavor. However, if you are looking for a subtle hint of vanilla, you can try substituting Mexican vanilla extract for regular vanilla extract.

What is the best vanilla to buy in Mexico?

Mexican vanilla is a type of vanilla extract that comes from Mexico. It is used primarily in baking and desserts. It is very similar to regular vanilla extract but it does not have any alcohol in it. It is usually sold in bottles with a green cap.

Where is vanilla from?

To create our origin-specific vanilla extracts, pastes, powders and beans, we use beans cultivated in three specific regions–Madagascar, Mexico and Tahiti. Each of our vanilla products has its own unique influence on a dish, based on the product’s specific benefits and ideal culinary uses, as well as the distinct flavor imparted from where the vanilla was grown.

Where are vanilla beans grown?

To create our origin-specific vanilla extracts, pastes, powders, beans and sugars, we use beans cultivated in three specific regions–Madagascar, Mexico and Tahiti. Each of our vanilla products has its own unique influence on a dish, based on the product’s specific benefits and ideal culinary uses, as well as the distinct flavor imparted from ...

What is the flavor of a sourdough bean?

Flavor Notes & Features: Moist, hand-selected beans with full, sweet, creamy and mellow flavor and velvety after-tones.

What is vanilla seeds used for?

Uses: Any cold or frozen application requiring unadulterated vanilla flavor. Increases the visual appeal of your dish by adding real vanilla seeds.

Can vanilla be used in cold?

Uses: Since this vanilla is susceptible to being damaged by heat, it’s best in cold or frozen dishes.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9