Moon Pie: Differences
- Origin. The story behind the inception of Moon Pie is a rather whimsical affair. ...
- Taste and Texture. Whoopie pies have a soft and delicate texture. ...
- Production. Although both feature a marshmallow center and a chocolaty exterior, Moon Pies and whoopie pies differ from each other quite a lot.
- Variation. ...
- Packaging. ...
What is the difference between a whoopie pie and a cake?
The classic whoopie pie features chocolate cakes with vanilla flavored filling, whereas whoopie pies of modern day can be found in all sorts of flavor combinations; mostly sweet, but even some savory! Where did the whoopie pie originate?
What is a moon pie?
A moon pie consists of a marshmallow sandwiched between two cookie-shaped graham crackers, which is then dipped in chocolate; also called marshmallow pies or scooter pies.
What is the difference between Moon Pie and Choco Pie?
Maker: In summary, on one hand, Moon Pies are an American-made invention. On the other hand, Choco Pies are a Korean sweet based on the American Moon Pie. Flavor: The basic premise of Moon and Choco Pies are pretty much the same.
What is the difference between a moon pie and a macaroon?
While moon pies are like cookies and whoopie pies like cakes, macaroons are confections. Sorry New England, but moon pies sound a lot better. I bet the crunch of the graham cracker contrasts really well with the fluffiness of the marshmallow.
Why do they call it a whoopie pie?
Some say Amish wives invented the whoopie pie from remnants of cake batter and frosting. According to the story, the name originated from the Amish men who, when they found these treats in their lunch boxes, would exclaim, “Whoopie!”
Why do they call them Moon Pies?
It all began in 1917 when a KY coal miner asked our traveling salesman for a snack “as big as the moon.” Earl Mitchell reported back and the bakery obliged with a tasty treat aptly named MoonPie. It was filling, fit in the lunch pail and the coal miners loved it. The rest, as they say, is history.
What are whoopie pies called in PA?
gobsWhoopie pies are considered a New England phenomenon and a Pennsylvania Amish tradition. They have also been known as a “gobs” in Western Pennsylvania (see Gob History below). They are one of Maine's best known and most loved comfort foods. People from Maine even claim that they were weaned on whoopie pies.
What was the original Moon Pie?
As the story goes, the original Moonpie—a graham cracker cookie and marshmallow sandwich dipped in chocolate and four inches in diameter—was first made in 1917, after traveling salesman Earl Mitchell attempted to answer the hungry pleas of local miners.
Is a wagon wheel the same as a MoonPie?
Wagon Wheels are available internationally and feature a similar profile to the MoonPie, but they were "invented" long after the Southern favorite, in 1948. Choco Pies are popular in South Korea, but they were directly inspired by the MoonPie.
Why is Sheldon MoonPie?
So, why is Sheldon called Moonpie? Well, he has a rather interesting explanation for it: "She calls me Moonpie because I am nummy-nummy and she could just eat me up." It sounds like it'll be better if the name comes from a lover than a grandmother but it's still an adorable one anyway.
What is a Maine whoopie pie?
A true Maine 'whoopie' consists of two dark-chocolate rounds, around the size of a hamburger, with a rich, dense filling sandwiched in-between. Some bakers have adapted this traditional treat to include pumpkin or gingerbread rounds, typically offered during the festive fall season.
What dessert is Maine known for?
blueberry pieIn 2011, the Maine State Legislature designated blueberry pie, made with wild Maine Blueberries, as the official state dessert. Wild blueberries are harvested from late July to early September in Maine.
What is Pennsylvania's state dessert?
As it turns out, Pennsylvania does not have an official dessert. It does have an official cookie – the chocolate chip cookie.
What is the best MoonPie flavor?
Our findings are as follows: The original MoonPie is most superior and banana is the worst (unless you're friend-of-the-blog/wife-of-the-Jason Sarah, in which case banana is for some reason your favorite). Vanilla is a MoonPie for people who don't like chocolate and also aren't interesting.
Why do they throw MoonPies at parades?
The reasoning? They are soft and have some weight to them, so when the ladies' tossed them, they had some leverage. They were looking for something economical, and MoonPies checked all of the boxes. They brought them back to Mobile and it caught on as a novelty.”
Why does Mobile Alabama drop a MoonPie?
Since New Year's Eve 2008, the city of Mobile has been lowering a 12-foot-tall lighted mechanical moon pie to celebrate the coming of the new year alongside performances from national musical acts.
What is MoonPie slang for?
Moonpie is the nickname used for Sheldon by his grandmother, who he in turn calls Meemaw.
What does MoonPie mean?
1. An American confection consisting of two round graham cookies, with marshmallow filing in the centre, dipped in a flavoured coating. It is often associated with the cuisine of the American South, traditionally accompanied by an RC Cola.
Why does Mobile Alabama drop a MoonPie?
Since New Year's Eve 2008, the city of Mobile has been lowering a 12-foot-tall lighted mechanical moon pie to celebrate the coming of the new year alongside performances from national musical acts.
Are Scooter Pies and MoonPies the same?
Scooter Pies are a version of Moon Pies named after NY Yankees shortstop Phil "Scooter" Rizzuto. They have 2 graham-like crackers sandwiching a layer of marshmallow covered with chocolate.
What is a whoopie pie?
According to What's Cooking America, the Whoopie Pies in Maine are about the size of a hamburger, created by taking two large, soft cookies and sandwiching them around fluffy, white marshmallow fluff or creme.
What is a moonpie?
Chowhound states the classic MoonPie is round and enrobed in a thin layer of chocolate. When you bite into one or cut it open, you'll find two soft graham cracker cookies surrounding a marshmallow filling. Over the years, many flavors have been added alongside the classic chocolate, ranging from strawberry to banana to coconut. Soda brand RC Cola and MoonPie used to be considered a classic combo, as evidenced in a song by country star Big Bill Lister.
What is the difference between a Maine whoopie pie and a Pennsylvania gob?
Experts agree that the biggest difference between a Maine whoopie pie and a Pennsylvania gob is the use of commercial marshmallow Fluff in the Maine version, versus homemade marshmallow fluff in the Amish version.
What is a whoopie pie?
The whoopie pie, a beloved American dessert, is a baked good comprised of two mound-shaped cookie-cakes with a creamy marshmallow-based filling sandwiched between them. The classic whoopie pie features chocolate cakes with vanilla flavored filling, whereas whoopie pies of modern day can be found in all sorts of flavor combinations; mostly sweet, but even some savory!
Where did marshmallow flouff originate?
According to marshmallowfluff.com (the website for the commercial manufacturer of Marshmallow Fluff), the origins of Marshmallow Fluff go back as far as 1917. A man from Somerville, MA, named Archibald Query was making the sweet concoction in his kitchen and selling it door-to-door. Wartime shortages during WWI forced his production to a halt, but once the war was over, he was open to selling the formula. Two young candy makers, H. Allen Durkee and Fred L Mower, purchased the formula for $500, then naming the confection "Toot Sweet Marshmallow Fluff," but the "Toot Sweet" part didn't last. The company's records show a sale in April, 1920 of three 1-gallon cans at $1.00 per gallon. By 1930, Durkee-Mower had the largest distribution of marshmallow cream in New England.
Where did whoopie pie originate?
Historical records of whoopie pies from the early 1900's have traced its birthplace to any one of the following US states: New Hampshire, Virginia, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Maine.
What is the Orion spring flavor?
Each year, Orion releases a limited edition spring flavor. Examples include strawberry jam in 2017, pistachio and berry in 2019, and strawberry blossom in 2020. In North Korea, workers at Kaesong Industrial Complex received Choco Pies in place of cash bonuses before the complex closed in 2013. Often, the workers would sell their Choco Pies ...
What was the first company to make choco pie?
The first company to make and produce the ‘Orion Choco Pie’ in South Korea is Orion Confectionery. At the time, the company was known as Tongyang Confectionary. The snack became so immensely popular that they renamed the company after it. Thus, the name Orion Confectionery was born.
What is a moon pie?
A Moon Pie (also spelled MoonPie) is a sweet treat made from marshmallow sandwiched between two graham cookies which is then dipped in a flavored coating. While the chocolate coating is the most traditional and classic version, other Moon Pie flavors include salted caramel, banana, vanilla, strawberry, and more.
What bakery named their pie moon?
A popular tale, often repeated by Chattanooga Bakery, tells that the miner asked for it to be ‘as big as the moon.’ As such, Chattanooga Bakery named their product Moon Pie!
When was Choco Pies published?
Written by Emily Published on March 11, 2021 in Lifestyle and Culinary Tips. A while back, we wrote a blog post listing some of the most popular Korean snacks available to buy online or that you can make at home. In that article, we listed Choco Pies as one of the most popular and well-known snacks available in and out of South Korea.
Where are choco pie snacks popular?
In that article, we listed Choco Pies as one of the most popular and well-known snacks available in and out of South Korea. Hey, they are so popular in North Korea that people sell them on the North Korean black market for hefty prices! While reading all about Choco Pies, I learned that the creator based them on the ‘Moon Pie.’.
How tall is the moon pie in Alabama?
Since 2008, Mobile, Alabama has lowered a 12-foot tall lighted mechanical Moon Pie during the countdown to celebrate the coming new year.
Definitions
- Moon Pie
A snack food popular in the Southern United States. A moon pie consists of a marshmallow sandwiched between two cookie-shaped graham crackers, which is then dipped in chocolate; also called marshmallow pies or scooter pies. - Whoopie Pie
A confection of two small and flat chocolate cakes with cream frosting in the middle; also called whoopee pie, black-and-white; Maine and Massachusetts are famous for whoopie pies.
Origins
- Moon Pies
Moon pies hail from a bakery in Chattanooga, Tennessee circa 1919. They’re widely enjoyed in the South. They were popular with working men in the 1930s when the Great Depression was going on, because they were filling, and I imagine, fairly cheap. - Whoopie Pies
Whoopie pies came from a bakery in Lewiston, Maine and were first sold in 1925. These treats can be found throughout New England and in the Pennsylvania Dutch community. Legend has it they got their name from farmers who cried out, “Whoopie!” when they found one in their lunchbox packed by their wives.
What The Difference Really Is
- Moon pies consist of round graham crackers, which whoopie pies don’t have – see above picture, that’s a moon pie. The whole thing is dipped in chocolate. There’s some marshmallow fluff in the middle. (Although the Dictionary.com definition of moon pies says “cream frosting” everything else I’ve seen, including the makers of the trademarked moon pies, says marshmallow.) Whoopie pies are two pieces of chocolate cake. There is a whole l…
Bonus Dessert: Macaroons
- In case you were wondering, macaroons, which look similar to our two food items we’re examining today, are made with almond paste, egg whites, and freshly ground almonds or coconut. While moon pies are like cookies and whoopie pies like cakes, macaroons are confections.
The Verdict
- Sorry New England, but moon pies sound a lot better. I bet the crunch of the graham cracker contrasts really well with the fluffiness of the marshmallow.