Receiving Helpdesk

what is considered middle class in nyc

by Maye Thompson Published 3 years ago Updated 3 years ago

In New York state
New York state
New York is a state in the Northeastern United States. It is sometimes called New York State to distinguish it from its largest city, New York City. With a total area of 54,556 square miles (141,300 km2), New York is the 27th largest state geographically.
https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › New_York_(state)
, a two-person family would be considered middle class if the household's income range is between $46,597 and $139,098. A three-person middle-class family's income would range from $55,155 to $164,644, and a four-person family in the middle tier would have income between $67,252.59 to $200,754.
Jun 3, 2021

Full Answer

What is the median household income in New York?

States with the Highest Median Household Income

  1. District of Columbia. The nation's capital, Washington, D.C., has the highest median household income in the United States of $92,266.
  2. Maryland. Maryland's median household income is $86,738, making it the second-highest in the country. ...
  3. Massachusetts. ...
  4. New Jersey. ...
  5. Hawaii. ...
  6. California. ...
  7. Connecticut. ...
  8. Washington. ...
  9. New Hampshire. ...
  10. Colorado. ...

How much money to be middle class?

Inflation makes the middle class a moving target, but that is just one piece of this complicated puzzle. Even agreeing on what income levels make someone middle-class is not easy. For our purposes, the chosen standard is the OECD definition, which is anyone making between 75% and 200% of the median income.

What income is considered middle class for a single person?

Pew defines “middle class” as a person earning between two-thirds and twice the median American household income, which in 2019 was $68,703, according to the United States Census Bureau. That puts the base salary to be in the middle class just shy of $46,000.

What income level is considered middle class in your state?

What is considered ... median household income. However, because the cost of living and average income varies so widely from state to state, the income needed to be "middle class" in one state ...

What is considered upper middle class in NYC?

In NYC , a combined income husband and wife of 500k is the start of upper middle class. 500k *1-40% tax rate - 310,000 k per year or 20k a year on restaurants, 20k for groceries, 50k for nanny, 60,000 for rent, 40k for school for two kids private/cheap private.

What is middle class in NYC for a single person?

Range of household incomes needed to be considered middle class, by family sizeStateSingleCoupleNew York$30,164 – $90,492$42,658 – $127,975North Carolina$23,719 – $71,157$33,544 – $100,631North Dakota$23,875 – $71,626$33,765 – $101,295Ohio$23,301 – $69,904$32,953 – $98,85948 more rows•Dec 12, 2020

What is upper class income in New York?

In New York City, you'll need to make at least $144,541 to be considered a “rich” person in the top 20% of the city's 8 million-plus residents. The ultra-rich, or the top 5% of earners in NYC, make way more: $585,902 on average, according to the analysis.Dec 9, 2021

What is a livable salary in NYC?

Recommended Salary in New York City To live comfortably, a resident would need to earn at least $12,489 monthly before taxes. That's pretty steep. If you chose to live in the more affordable Bronx borough, you'd need to earn three times the $2,312 monthly rent rate before taxes, which amounts to $6,936.Jan 31, 2022

Is 50k a year middle class?

Statisticians say middle class is a household income between $25,000 and $100,000 a year. Anything above $100,000 is deemed “upper middle class”.

What is upper class salary?

Those making less than $42,000 make up the lower-income bracket, while those making more than $126,000 make up the upper-income bracket.

What percentage of New Yorkers make over 100k?

Nearly 30% of New Yorkers make six-figure salaries. But a high income doesn't render you impervious to the city's high taxes and infamously high cost of living. From tiny, 260-square-foot apartments to above-average-priced milk, here's what living in New York on a $100,000 salary can really look like.Feb 27, 2020

What is a good salary for a single person in NYC?

That's $30,294 per year after taxes, which means that to live a reasonably comfortable life in New York City, a single person would need to make a salary of roughly $40,000 per year. This is a comfortable (though far from indulgent) budget.

What is middle income in NYC?

In New York City, a middle class income is considered between $61,000 and $180,000 for a household of three.Mar 24, 2021

Is 51k a good salary?

With the proper budget and discipline, $50,000 is an excellent salary. In 2020, the median household income in the United States was about $67,000. Your debt load, dependents, and assets will determine how comfortably you can live with an income of $50k.Mar 1, 2022

Is 80k a good salary in NYC?

Your average landlord will require that your annual income be 40 times the monthly rent. For instance, if you want to live in a $2,000/month studio apartment in Manhattan (which is on the low end of the range for apartments in Manhattan, but not uncommonly so), you'll need $80,000 a year.

Can you live on 50k a year in NYC?

“I definitely think you can live comfortably on a salary of $50,000, even in New York City,” says Haskins. “It's an expensive city, but I think if you know where your money is going and you recognize what your priorities are, it's totally doable.”Aug 22, 2019

How much do you have to make to be a middle class person in New York?

The newspaper determined that to be considered middle class in New York City, a person must earn between $45,000 and $134,000 per year. (Some NYC residents argued in the article that $250,000 still qualifies as upper middle class.) In other parts of the country, middle class means annual earnings between $33,000 and $100,000.

What is middle class income?

Americans with incomes from $30,000 categorize themselves as middle class and a Pew Research Center survey showed that about half of Americans identify themselves as part of it. But an individual or family's location is "everything" in understanding what's middle class, says The Wall Street Journal. This is because the "middle" is generally defined by who's at the top and who's at the bottom -- markers that vary greatly from state to state, and even county to county. The median household income in Mississippi is $39,079, but in Maryland it's $67,469. This obviously affects what's "middle class" in either state. (County-to-county median incomes reveal even greater disparities.)

Is apartment maintenance high in New York City?

Nainan adds that apartment maintenance fees are also very high in New York City, and that food, clothing and some related travel expenses can easily eat away at savings. His thoughts are echoed by Mikey Rox, owner of the public relations and marketing firm Paper Rox Scissors.

How do you define the middle class?

Most researchers define the middle class by calculating the median income for a place, and grouping people into certain percentages above or below the absolute middle. Image. The death of the middle class has been forecast for years by The New York Times and New York magazine, among many others.

What are middle class jobs?

The shift toward a knowledge-based and service economy has created a new set of middle-class jobs, like graphic designer, publishing professional and health care administrator. Positions that would nudge a family into the upper class elsewhere — say, vice president or director of strategy — and professions like psychologist are solidly middle class in Manhattan.

How much money do you need to make to live in Manhattan?

But if you are defining middle class by lifestyle, to accommodate the cost of living in Manhattan, that salary would have to fall between $80,000 and $235,000. This means someone making $70,000 a year in other parts of the country would need to make $166,000 in Manhattan to enjoy the same purchasing power.

How much does a middle class person make in a year?

By one measure, in cities like Houston or Phoenix — places considered by statisticians to be more typical of average United States incomes than New York — a solidly middle-class life can be had for wages that fall between $33,000 and $100,000 a year.

Is Maya Tolstoy middle class?

Maya Tolstoy, an associate professor at Columbia, could be considered middle class in Manhattan. She and her son are able to afford the city in part because their building is owned by the university.

Is 70,000 a middle class income?

A $70,000 annual income is middle class for a family of four, according to the median response in a recent Pew Research Center survey, and yet people at a wide range of income levels, including those making less than $30,000 and more than $100,000 a year, said they, too, belonged to the middle.

Is middle class a question?

Ask people around the country, “Are you middle class?” and the answer is likely to be yes. But ask the same question in Manhattan , and people often pause in confusion, unsure exactly what you mean.

What is considered middle class?

The Pew Research Center defines middle class, or middle-income households, as those with incomes that are two-thirds to double the U.S. median household income.

What is middle class income?

The Pew Research Center defines middle class, or middle-income households, as those with incomes that are two-thirds to double the U.S. median household income. Check Out: The Economy and Your Money: All You Need To Know.

Why is middle class income more or less?

However, because the cost of living and average income varies so widely from state to state, the income needed to be "middle class" in one state could be much more or less than what it takes to be middle class in another.

What is the difference between middle class and working class?

If you’re a middle-class family, you make more money than the working class but less money than the upper class. In other words, you fall in the middle of these two tiers.

What do middle class families want?

They want the proverbial white picket fence, homeownership, and a secure retirement. They typically have more college education than lower-income classes, and have white-collar jobs such as managers, administrators, lawyers, and accountants.

What is the middle class income for 2020?

For 2020, this meant you were middle class if you made $39,479 to $109,732, which is slightly different from Pew Research Center’s range. 2

Why do middle class families work more hours?

Middle-class families are also prone to the money versus time squeeze. Either they work more hours to make more money, leaving less leisure time; or they sacrifice money for more time with family, lowering their lifetime earnings and chances of having adequate financial security.

Is middle class income based on income?

Middle-class status isn’t based on income alone. It also depends on your household size, location, and other factors.

Can middle class people live paycheck to paycheck?

Although the middle class can live paycheck to paycheck, they usually have enough disposable income to spend on entertainment and the occasional vacation.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
8.3.21PHP Version1.96sRequest Duration2MBMemory UsageGET {post}Route
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\QueryFormatter:...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\QueryFormatter:...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: Callables of the form ["Swift_SmtpTransport", "Swift_Transport_EsmtpTranspor...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\SimpleFormatter...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: Creation of dynamic property Barryvdh\Debugbar\DataFormatter\SimpleFormatter...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • warninglog[15:12:20] LOG.warning: json_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($json) of type string is deprec...
  • Booting (10.7ms)
  • Application (1.95s)
  • 1 x Application (99.44%)
    1.95s
    1 x Booting (0.55%)
    10.70ms
    7 templates were rendered
    • themes.DevBlog.content.post (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/content/post.blade.php)34blade
      Params
      0
      post
      1
      postContent
      2
      author
      3
      updated_at
      4
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      5
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      6
      bing_related_keywords
      7
      google_related_keywords
      8
      bing_news_title
      9
      bing_news_description
      10
      bing_videos
      11
      bing_images
      12
      bing_search_result_title
      13
      bing_search_result_description
      14
      bing_search_result_url
      15
      bing_paa_questions
      16
      bing_paa_answers
      17
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      18
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      19
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      20
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      21
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      22
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      23
      google_faq_questions
      24
      google_faq_answers
      25
      google_rich_snippet
      26
      google_search_result
      27
      indexedArray
      28
      total_images
      29
      total_videos
      30
      settings
      31
      url_current
      32
      menus
      33
      sidebar
    • themes.DevBlog.layouts.master (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/layouts/master.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.head (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/head.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.header (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/header.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.navbar (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/navbar.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.footer (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/footer.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    • themes.DevBlog.panels.scripts (resources/views/themes/DevBlog/panels/scripts.blade.php)41blade
      Params
      0
      __env
      1
      app
      2
      errors
      3
      post
      4
      postContent
      5
      author
      6
      updated_at
      7
      bing_rich_snippet_text
      8
      bing_rich_snippet_link
      9
      bing_related_keywords
      10
      google_related_keywords
      11
      bing_news_title
      12
      bing_news_description
      13
      bing_videos
      14
      bing_images
      15
      bing_search_result_title
      16
      bing_search_result_description
      17
      bing_search_result_url
      18
      bing_paa_questions
      19
      bing_paa_answers
      20
      bing_slider_faq_questions
      21
      bing_slider_faq_answers
      22
      bing_pop_faq_questions
      23
      bing_pop_faq_answers
      24
      bing_tab_faq_questions
      25
      bing_tab_faq_answers
      26
      google_faq_questions
      27
      google_faq_answers
      28
      google_rich_snippet
      29
      google_search_result
      30
      indexedArray
      31
      total_images
      32
      total_videos
      33
      settings
      34
      url_current
      35
      menus
      36
      sidebar
      37
      i
      38
      __currentLoopData
      39
      loop
      40
      item
    uri
    GET {post}
    middleware
    web, checkdate
    as
    post.show
    controller
    App\Http\Controllers\Frontend\json_data\PostController@show
    namespace
    where
    file
    app/Http/Controllers/Frontend/json_data/PostController.php:18-166
    7 statements were executed1.93s
    • select * from `posts` where `published_at` <= '2025-06-21 15:12:20' and `slug` = 'what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc' and `posts`.`deleted_at` is null limit 1
      2.69ms/app/Providers/RouteServiceProvider.php:54receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 2025-06-21 15:12:20
      • 1. what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc
      Backtrace
      • 15. /app/Providers/RouteServiceProvider.php:54
      • 18. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Router.php:842
      • 19. Route binding:39
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 21. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Foundation/Http/Middleware/VerifyCsrfToken.php:78
    • select * from `json_post_contents` where `json_post_contents`.`post_id` = 137452 and `json_post_contents`.`post_id` is not null and `rewrite_id` = 0
      3.38msmiddleware::checkdate:30receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 137452
      • 1. 0
      Backtrace
      • 19. middleware::checkdate:30
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 21. /vendor/laravel/jetstream/src/Http/Middleware/ShareInertiaData.php:61
      • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Pipeline/Pipeline.php:167
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Middleware/SubstituteBindings.php:50
    • select * from `nova_menu_menus` where `slug` = 'header' limit 1
      520μs/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:32receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. header
      Backtrace
      • 15. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:32
      • 17. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 18. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 19. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
    • select * from `nova_menu_menu_items` where `nova_menu_menu_items`.`menu_id` = 1 and `nova_menu_menu_items`.`menu_id` is not null and `parent_id` is null order by `parent_id` asc, `order` asc, `name` asc
      420μs/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 1
      Backtrace
      • 19. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35
      • 20. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:33
      • 22. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
    • select * from `nova_menu_menu_items` where `nova_menu_menu_items`.`parent_id` in (1) order by `order` asc
      350μs/vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Backtrace
      • 24. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/Models/Menu.php:35
      • 25. /vendor/outl1ne/nova-menu-builder/src/helpers.php:33
      • 27. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
      • 28. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:45
      • 29. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:261
    • select `id`, `post_title`, `slug` from `posts` where `status` = 'publish' and `posts`.`deleted_at` is null order by RAND() limit 10
      1.92s/app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:22receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. publish
      Backtrace
      • 14. /app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:22
      • 15. /app/View/Composers/SidebarView.php:12
      • 16. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:124
      • 17. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:162
      • 20. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Concerns/ManagesEvents.php:177
    • select * from `fake_users` where `fake_users`.`id` = 21348 limit 1
      740μsview::2dd102cf0462e89a4d4d8bc77355d767652bf9aa:15receivinghelpdeskask
      Metadata
      Bindings
      • 0. 21348
      Backtrace
      • 21. view::2dd102cf0462e89a4d4d8bc77355d767652bf9aa:15
      • 23. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:108
      • 24. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/PhpEngine.php:58
      • 25. /vendor/livewire/livewire/src/ComponentConcerns/RendersLivewireComponents.php:69
      • 26. /vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:61
    App\Models\FakeUser
    1
    Outl1ne\MenuBuilder\Models\MenuItem
    1
    Outl1ne\MenuBuilder\Models\Menu
    1
    App\Models\JsonPostContent
    1
    App\Models\Post
    11
        _token
        wSmC3JyyMlRZ44cHH1vBZT7j2yiRrY3lRYKLV1UV
        _previous
        array:1 [ "url" => "https://receivinghelpdesk.com/ask/what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc" ]
        _flash
        array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ]
        PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA
        []
        path_info
        /what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc
        status_code
        200
        
        status_text
        OK
        format
        html
        content_type
        text/html; charset=UTF-8
        request_query
        []
        
        request_request
        []
        
        request_headers
        0 of 0
        array:25 [ "cookie" => array:1 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik1oL25PVUphRno5UjEza3hrT0RuckE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiM2dGTFVZdDJhMkE1akNtdCtid1RZUzYydVVySDR5UlhpL3dxc0NvVThKUHZYNDVCYlZBMFNCN0dDd0ErUlhQV2xaaFBHOThBaDV2bm5NY1I5djRkZHF0Mlg5aXEwc0MzeGRCQ3h4YWJXanphczBUWkNEdUF5ZnE4RWpKeVRiRVQiLCJtYWMiOiIwMDkwNTg5YjcwZGIzOTk1M2Q4YTU2ZTNiZjg1ZWNmOGFkNmYzYmEwODg3YWQxZDA5OWNmYWRjOGNjZjAyYTYzIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IndTZ0JaUjRFZmhaWUh2MlNqZ1R3V2c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiMUF6NWI2eUlER25jNVFnVittSGp1aEhrRHl5YjVIVHRaYUlwRm9xTnVHMTFmWTU4VlBmaGVVa3JpSDRQS21yV1owcmNneEUyZlFDVlV1bUNNbkpYWHliazVQWm0xY3FaNExVazRUV0k5Q1FIZUl0cGkwUzdobDJVdGhJNy9GNGIiLCJtYWMiOiI5OGY1NTE1NDk1MGMyOGNkNzQ5NjQwOGUxNmY1MTdmNjRiMTI1NDFkYWE5YjBjYjA3YjY4ZDU4YWY0Y2JmMWZjIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; _pk_id.64.7c30=ead0544dfdf68d1d.1750498938.; _pk_ses.64.7c30=1XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik1oL25PVUphRno5UjEza3hrT0RuckE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiM2dGTFVZdDJhMkE1akNtdCtid1RZUzYydVVySDR5UlhpL3dxc0NvVThKUHZYNDVCYlZBMFNCN0dDd0ErUlhQV2xaaFBHO" ] "cf-ipcountry" => array:1 [ 0 => "US" ] "cf-connecting-ip" => array:1 [ 0 => "216.73.216.243" ] "cdn-loop" => array:1 [ 0 => "cloudflare; loops=1" ] "sec-fetch-mode" => array:1 [ 0 => "navigate" ] "sec-fetch-site" => array:1 [ 0 => "none" ] "accept" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" ] "user-agent" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" ] "upgrade-insecure-requests" => array:1 [ 0 => "1" ] "sec-ch-ua-platform" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Windows"" ] "sec-ch-ua-mobile" => array:1 [ 0 => "?0" ] "sec-ch-ua" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Chromium";v="130", "HeadlessChrome";v="130", "Not?A_Brand";v="99"" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "accept-encoding" => array:1 [ 0 => "gzip, br" ] "cf-ray" => array:1 [ 0 => "95328e2a9da245f5-ORD" ] "priority" => array:1 [ 0 => "u=0, i" ] "sec-fetch-dest" => array:1 [ 0 => "document" ] "sec-fetch-user" => array:1 [ 0 => "?1" ] "cf-visitor" => array:1 [ 0 => "{"scheme":"https"}" ] "connection" => array:1 [ 0 => "close" ] "x-forwarded-proto" => array:1 [ 0 => "https" ] "x-forwarded-for" => array:1 [ 0 => "216.73.216.243, 172.69.17.30" ] "x-server-addr" => array:1 [ 0 => "154.12.239.204" ] "host" => array:1 [ 0 => "receivinghelpdesk.com" ] ]
        request_server
        0 of 0
        array:56 [ "USER" => "runcloud" "HOME" => "/home/runcloud" "SCRIPT_NAME" => "/ask/index.php" "REQUEST_URI" => "/ask/what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc" "QUERY_STRING" => "" "REQUEST_METHOD" => "GET" "SERVER_PROTOCOL" => "HTTP/1.0" "GATEWAY_INTERFACE" => "CGI/1.1" "REDIRECT_URL" => "/ask/what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc" "REMOTE_PORT" => "34776" "SCRIPT_FILENAME" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/ask/index.php" "SERVER_ADMIN" => "you@example.com" "CONTEXT_DOCUMENT_ROOT" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/" "CONTEXT_PREFIX" => "" "REQUEST_SCHEME" => "http" "DOCUMENT_ROOT" => "/home/runcloud/webapps/ReceivingHelpDesk/" "REMOTE_ADDR" => "172.69.17.30" "SERVER_PORT" => "80" "SERVER_ADDR" => "127.0.0.1" "SERVER_NAME" => "receivinghelpdesk.com" "SERVER_SOFTWARE" => "Apache/2.4.63 (Unix) OpenSSL/1.1.1f" "SERVER_SIGNATURE" => "" "LD_LIBRARY_PATH" => "/RunCloud/Packages/apache2-rc/lib" "PATH" => "/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin" "HTTP_COOKIE" => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik1oL25PVUphRno5UjEza3hrT0RuckE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiM2dGTFVZdDJhMkE1akNtdCtid1RZUzYydVVySDR5UlhpL3dxc0NvVThKUHZYNDVCYlZBMFNCN0dDd0ErUlhQV2xaaFBHOThBaDV2bm5NY1I5djRkZHF0Mlg5aXEwc0MzeGRCQ3h4YWJXanphczBUWkNEdUF5ZnE4RWpKeVRiRVQiLCJtYWMiOiIwMDkwNTg5YjcwZGIzOTk1M2Q4YTU2ZTNiZjg1ZWNmOGFkNmYzYmEwODg3YWQxZDA5OWNmYWRjOGNjZjAyYTYzIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6IndTZ0JaUjRFZmhaWUh2MlNqZ1R3V2c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiMUF6NWI2eUlER25jNVFnVittSGp1aEhrRHl5YjVIVHRaYUlwRm9xTnVHMTFmWTU4VlBmaGVVa3JpSDRQS21yV1owcmNneEUyZlFDVlV1bUNNbkpYWHliazVQWm0xY3FaNExVazRUV0k5Q1FIZUl0cGkwUzdobDJVdGhJNy9GNGIiLCJtYWMiOiI5OGY1NTE1NDk1MGMyOGNkNzQ5NjQwOGUxNmY1MTdmNjRiMTI1NDFkYWE5YjBjYjA3YjY4ZDU4YWY0Y2JmMWZjIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; _pk_id.64.7c30=ead0544dfdf68d1d.1750498938.; _pk_ses.64.7c30=1XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6Ik1oL25PVUphRno5UjEza3hrT0RuckE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiM2dGTFVZdDJhMkE1akNtdCtid1RZUzYydVVySDR5UlhpL3dxc0NvVThKUHZYNDVCYlZBMFNCN0dDd0ErUlhQV2xaaFBHO" "HTTP_CF_IPCOUNTRY" => "US" "HTTP_CF_CONNECTING_IP" => "216.73.216.243" "HTTP_CDN_LOOP" => "cloudflare; loops=1" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_MODE" => "navigate" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_SITE" => "none" "HTTP_ACCEPT" => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" "HTTP_USER_AGENT" => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" "HTTP_UPGRADE_INSECURE_REQUESTS" => "1" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_PLATFORM" => ""Windows"" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA_MOBILE" => "?0" "HTTP_SEC_CH_UA" => ""Chromium";v="130", "HeadlessChrome";v="130", "Not?A_Brand";v="99"" "HTTP_CACHE_CONTROL" => "no-cache" "HTTP_PRAGMA" => "no-cache" "HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING" => "gzip, br" "HTTP_CF_RAY" => "95328e2a9da245f5-ORD" "HTTP_PRIORITY" => "u=0, i" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_DEST" => "document" "HTTP_SEC_FETCH_USER" => "?1" "HTTP_CF_VISITOR" => "{"scheme":"https"}" "HTTP_CONNECTION" => "close" "HTTP_X_FORWARDED_PROTO" => "https" "HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR" => "216.73.216.243, 172.69.17.30" "HTTP_X_SERVER_ADDR" => "154.12.239.204" "HTTP_HOST" => "receivinghelpdesk.com" "HTTPS" => "on" "REDIRECT_STATUS" => "200" "REDIRECT_HTTPS" => "on" "FCGI_ROLE" => "RESPONDER" "PHP_SELF" => "/ask/index.php" "REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT" => 1750498940.592 "REQUEST_TIME" => 1750498940 ]
        request_cookies
        0 of 0
        array:4 [ "XSRF-TOKEN" => "wSmC3JyyMlRZ44cHH1vBZT7j2yiRrY3lRYKLV1UV" "askhelpdesk_session" => "SvpsxkbQ6Q8Cesu8ngsf5HNhqZPwUpYTOxpYeH4F" "_pk_id_64_7c30" => null "_pk_ses_64_7c30" => null ]
        response_headers
        0 of 0
        array:7 [ "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html; charset=UTF-8" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "private, must-revalidate" ] "date" => array:1 [ 0 => "Sat, 21 Jun 2025 09:42:20 GMT" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "expires" => array:1 [ 0 => -1 ] "set-cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InI5S3VWR1hxZkVCcHQ1TFg0Y3ljQ3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVVU1RFRLc3VWT2d0UzV5SlBPZFU0MVExbHI5N3RLWHV0WGNPc2FOaDVkZGxmKys4ZzNHOEJKU1U2K2VZRDA0bi93RENmRUJpVUswQ0Y2M1hROGpKS1ZnU2ZTcUxqRWFoSkRmQ296YndsVnFoUW1SekJHbnJYbk5NK1Y4UnBOcjAiLCJtYWMiOiI3ZmVkNmFjN2I3ZjU3M2JlZWMyNzZlYmE0MzgzODc1MjcwYmI1ZjQwOWM0MWQxOTE2NDdiYmY5MGQ5NzIwZWQ2IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 21-Jun-2025 11:42:22 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; samesite=laxXSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InI5S3VWR1hxZkVCcHQ1TFg0Y3ljQ3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVVU1RFRLc3VWT2d0UzV5SlBPZFU0MVExbHI5N3RLWHV0WGNPc2FOaDVkZGxmKys4ZzNHOEJKU1U2K2VZRDA0bi93RENmR" 1 => "askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6Ilp0V1l2dlNLTDQvMVVXRDVYd1FkcUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidEs3NGR4UnlPQ2l1dDVJcEIvOEp1NzRtc0FzSzhjWUxNbDVPRHV0WkVzVEEyTHhOMkllYlM0UWlEcEJmQk5RcGFVUXNCeCtHU2pGVHhaak03QnA1Ni9GaEl2OFFGTytBbm81WkxwZ3RQeUpVZkdSc1h2MEJFVEp6bE1tTnZRWWkiLCJtYWMiOiI0ZDhhMjc1YTUxZGZmYWNlZWFiZmFjZGVlNTZmZDRkZTMyZTM4MjM3MDAxZWUxMmRjOWFlYmI0MzI1NTQyOGFkIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 21-Jun-2025 11:42:22 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; httponly; samesite=laxaskhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6Ilp0V1l2dlNLTDQvMVVXRDVYd1FkcUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidEs3NGR4UnlPQ2l1dDVJcEIvOEp1NzRtc0FzSzhjWUxNbDVPRHV0WkVzVEEyTHhOMkllYlM0UWlEcEJmQk5R" ] "Set-Cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InI5S3VWR1hxZkVCcHQ1TFg0Y3ljQ3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVVU1RFRLc3VWT2d0UzV5SlBPZFU0MVExbHI5N3RLWHV0WGNPc2FOaDVkZGxmKys4ZzNHOEJKU1U2K2VZRDA0bi93RENmRUJpVUswQ0Y2M1hROGpKS1ZnU2ZTcUxqRWFoSkRmQ296YndsVnFoUW1SekJHbnJYbk5NK1Y4UnBOcjAiLCJtYWMiOiI3ZmVkNmFjN2I3ZjU3M2JlZWMyNzZlYmE0MzgzODc1MjcwYmI1ZjQwOWM0MWQxOTE2NDdiYmY5MGQ5NzIwZWQ2IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 21-Jun-2025 11:42:22 GMT; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InI5S3VWR1hxZkVCcHQ1TFg0Y3ljQ3c9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVVU1RFRLc3VWT2d0UzV5SlBPZFU0MVExbHI5N3RLWHV0WGNPc2FOaDVkZGxmKys4ZzNHOEJKU1U2K2VZRDA0bi93RENmR" 1 => "askhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6Ilp0V1l2dlNLTDQvMVVXRDVYd1FkcUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidEs3NGR4UnlPQ2l1dDVJcEIvOEp1NzRtc0FzSzhjWUxNbDVPRHV0WkVzVEEyTHhOMkllYlM0UWlEcEJmQk5RcGFVUXNCeCtHU2pGVHhaak03QnA1Ni9GaEl2OFFGTytBbm81WkxwZ3RQeUpVZkdSc1h2MEJFVEp6bE1tTnZRWWkiLCJtYWMiOiI0ZDhhMjc1YTUxZGZmYWNlZWFiZmFjZGVlNTZmZDRkZTMyZTM4MjM3MDAxZWUxMmRjOWFlYmI0MzI1NTQyOGFkIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Sat, 21-Jun-2025 11:42:22 GMT; path=/; httponlyaskhelpdesk_session=eyJpdiI6Ilp0V1l2dlNLTDQvMVVXRDVYd1FkcUE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidEs3NGR4UnlPQ2l1dDVJcEIvOEp1NzRtc0FzSzhjWUxNbDVPRHV0WkVzVEEyTHhOMkllYlM0UWlEcEJmQk5R" ] ]
        session_attributes
        0 of 0
        array:4 [ "_token" => "wSmC3JyyMlRZ44cHH1vBZT7j2yiRrY3lRYKLV1UV" "_previous" => array:1 [ "url" => "https://receivinghelpdesk.com/ask/what-is-considered-middle-class-in-nyc" ] "_flash" => array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ] "PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA" => [] ]